UK vs US health cover at a glance
The two systems work very differently, which is why health insurance questions have different answers on each side of the Atlantic.
| United Kingdom | United States | |
|---|---|---|
| Main public system | NHS, free at the point of use for residents | Medicare (65+), Medicaid (low income), Marketplace plans |
| Is insurance required? | No | No federal penalty; some states require cover |
| Role of private insurance | Optional top-up for faster or private treatment | Main source of cover for most working-age people |
| When can you buy? | Any time | Open Enrollment or a Special Enrollment Period |
| Pre-existing conditions | Usually excluded by private policies, at least at first | ACA plans cannot refuse or charge more |
| Marketplace 'metal' tiers | Not applicable | Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum: plan pays on average about 60%, 70%, 80% or 90% of costs |
Sources: NHS · HealthCare.gov
Visitors and some visa holders in the UK pay the Immigration Health Surcharge to use the NHS.
US plan cost estimator: premium is only the start
Compare what a plan might cost you in a quiet year and a bad year. Enter the figures from the plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.
Sources: HealthCare.gov glossary
Illustrative. Copays, out-of-network care and services that are not covered work differently. Premium tax credits can lower the premium.
US Marketplace 'metal' tiers
The tier describes how costs are shared on average, not the quality of care.
| Tier | The plan pays about | You pay about | Typical fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bronze | 60% | 40% | Lowest premium, highest costs when you need care |
| Silver | 70% | 30% | Middle ground; the only tier with cost-sharing reductions if you qualify |
| Gold | 80% | 20% | Higher premium, lower costs when you need care |
| Platinum | 90% | 10% | Highest premium, lowest costs at the point of care |
Sources: HealthCare.gov: plan categories
United States: seven ways people get covered
| Coverage | Who it is for | Where to start |
|---|---|---|
| Employer plan | Employees and often their families | Your employer's benefits office |
| Marketplace (ACA) plan | People without employer cover; subsidies depend on income | HealthCare.gov |
| Medicaid | People with low incomes; rules vary by state | Medicaid.gov |
| CHIP | Children in families that earn too much for Medicaid | InsureKidsNow.gov |
| Medicare | People aged 65 and over, and some younger disabled people | medicare.ngo |
| COBRA | People leaving a job who want to keep the employer plan, usually at full cost | US Department of Labor |
| TRICARE and VA care | Military members, veterans and families | TRICARE |
Thinking about UK private medical insurance? Five questions first
- What do you want it for?UK policies are mainly for faster planned treatment of new, short-term conditions. Emergency care stays with the NHS.
- What is excluded?Pre-existing and chronic (long-term) conditions are normally excluded. Ask how the insurer defines both.
- How will it be underwritten?'Full medical underwriting' asks about your history up front. 'Moratorium' asks nothing but excludes recent conditions automatically, usually those from the last five years.
- What are the limits?Check outpatient limits, the hospital list, the excess and whether cancer drugs not available on the NHS are covered.
- What will it cost in five years?Premiums usually rise with age and after claims. Ask for the insurer's recent increases.
Sources: MoneyHelper
UK: insure or pay as you go?
Compare the cost of private medical insurance over several years with paying for one private procedure yourself.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.
Illustrative. Insurance normally excludes pre-existing and long-term conditions; the NHS remains free at the point of use either way. Ask the hospital for a fixed-price package quote.
Eight questions before you buy UK private medical insurance
Signs a 'health plan' is not real insurance
- A cold call or text offering cheap cover 'ending today'.
- The seller will not send the full plan documents before you pay.
- It is described as a discount card, sharing ministry, fixed indemnity or short-term plan: these are not comprehensive cover and may not pay for pre-existing conditions.
- In the US: the site is not HealthCare.gov or your official state marketplace, yet claims to be 'the Obamacare site'.
- In the UK: the firm is not on the FCA Register.
Sources: HealthCare.gov · FCA Register
Health insurance glossary
- Deductible (US)
- What you pay for covered care each year before the plan starts to pay.
- Copay
- A fixed amount you pay for a visit or prescription.
- Coinsurance
- Your percentage share of a bill after the deductible.
- Out-of-pocket maximum
- The most you pay in a year for covered in-network care; after that the plan pays 100%.
- Network
- The doctors and hospitals the plan has contracts with. Care outside it can cost far more.
- Excess (UK)
- The amount you pay towards a claim, per claim or per year.
- Chronic condition
- A long-term condition that needs ongoing management rather than a cure; normally excluded from UK private cover.
- Open enrollment (US)
- The yearly window to buy or change Marketplace cover, starting 1 November in most states.
Sources: HealthCare.gov glossary
Health Insurance: questions and answers
How it works
Do I need private medical insurance in the UK?
UKNo. NHS care is available to people who are ordinarily resident in the UK; private medical insurance is optional and mainly covers faster or private treatment for eligible conditions.
Policies typically exclude emergency care, chronic conditions and some treatments. Check what is covered, any limits on outpatient care and how premiums rise with age.
Official sources: NHS – services · MoneyHelper
How do UK health insurers treat pre-existing conditions?
UKUsually through underwriting: either a moratorium, which commonly excludes recent conditions for an initial period, or full medical underwriting, where specific conditions are named as exclusions.
Under a moratorium you may not know what is excluded until you claim. Under full underwriting you know at the start. Ask the insurer to explain the terms before you buy.
Official sources: MoneyHelper · Financial Ombudsman Service
Is health insurance required by law in the US?
USUKThere is no longer a federal penalty for being uninsured, but a few states, including California, Massachusetts, New Jersey and Rhode Island, and Washington, D.C., have their own coverage requirement.
In the UK there is no requirement, because NHS care is available to residents. Some visa holders pay the Immigration Health Surcharge instead.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov
What happens to my health insurance when I leave a job?
USUKEmployer coverage usually ends at or shortly after your last day, but you can usually keep it through COBRA, paying the full cost, or switch to a Marketplace plan through a Special Enrollment Period.
You normally have 60 days after losing coverage to enrol in a Marketplace plan. In the UK, company private medical insurance ends with the job. Some insurers let you continue on an individual policy without new medical underwriting if you ask quickly.
Official sources: US Department of Labor – COBRA · HealthCare.gov – Special Enrollment Periods
Can I use health insurance as soon as I buy it?
USUKNot always. US Marketplace plans start on a set date after enrolment, and UK private medical insurance usually excludes conditions you had before joining, often for at least the first two years under 'moratorium' underwriting.
Some policies also have waiting periods for specific treatments. Read the start date, any waiting periods and the pre-existing condition rules before relying on a policy for planned treatment.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov · MoneyHelper
How do I claim on UK private medical insurance?
UKUsually you see your GP first for a referral, then contact the insurer for pre-authorisation before any consultation or treatment, so that the insurer confirms what it will pay.
Use a consultant and hospital on the insurer's list, and check whether the fees are covered in full. If the insurer refuses to pay, complain in writing and then go to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
Official sources: Financial Ombudsman Service · MoneyHelper
Can I cancel health insurance at any time?
UKUSIn the UK, yes: you have a 14-day cooling-off period, and after that you can usually cancel with notice. In the US, you can end a Marketplace plan at any time, but you may not be able to buy another until the next enrolment period.
Before cancelling, check whether a gap in cover would affect pre-existing condition cover on a future UK policy, or leave you uninsured in the US until the next enrolment window.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov · MoneyHelper
Costs, tax and value
Is health insurance tax deductible?
USUKIn the US, employer plan premiums are usually paid before tax, self-employed people may deduct premiums, and others can deduct medical costs only above a threshold if they itemise.
In the UK, private medical insurance provided by an employer is normally a taxable benefit in kind, so you pay tax on its value. Premiums for a policy you buy yourself are not tax deductible.
Official sources: IRS · GOV.UK – medical or dental benefits
What decides how much health insurance costs?
USUKIn the US, your premium depends on age, location, tobacco use, the plan's metal tier and whether you qualify for premium tax credits; in the UK, private medical insurance prices depend mainly on age, excess, hospital list and how pre-existing conditions are treated.
Look beyond the monthly premium. In the US, compare the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum. In the UK, check outpatient limits and whether cancer cover is full or limited.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov · MoneyHelper
Are health insurance brokers free to use?
USUKUsually yes to you, because they are paid commission by insurers, but that can influence which plans they show, so ask which insurers they compare.
In the US, free unbiased help with Marketplace plans is available from Navigators listed on HealthCare.gov. In the UK, a broker selling private medical insurance must be FCA-authorised or an appointed representative.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov · FCA Financial Services Register
Staying safe
How do I check that an insurer or broker is genuine?
UKUSIn the UK, look the firm up on the FCA Financial Services Register and use the contact details shown there, not those in an unsolicited message.
Fake insurance sellers and 'ghost brokers' often advertise cheap cover on social media or messaging apps. Check the firm's name, firm reference number and website against the register, and read the FCA's warning list before you pay.
In the United States, your state insurance department confirms whether a company or agent is licensed in your state.
Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · FCA ScamSmart · NAIC – state insurance departments
If things go wrong
How do I complain if my insurer rejects or delays a claim?
UKUSComplain to the insurer first; if you get a final response you disagree with, or no answer within eight weeks, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service for free.
Put your complaint in writing, say what you want the insurer to do, and keep copies of your policy, correspondence and evidence. You normally have six months from the insurer's final response to go to the ombudsman. You do not need to pay a claims company to do this.
In the United States, complaints go to your state insurance department.
Official sources: Financial Ombudsman Service – how to complain · NAIC – state insurance departments
In the United States
Can US health plans refuse cover for pre-existing conditions?
USPlans under the Affordable Care Act cannot refuse cover or charge you more because of a pre-existing condition.
You can generally enrol in a Marketplace plan during the annual open enrolment period, or at other times if a qualifying life event gives you a special enrolment period. Some short-term plans are not covered by these protections.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov – pre-existing conditions · HealthCare.gov
What do deductible, copay and out-of-pocket maximum mean?
USThe deductible is what you pay before the plan starts paying; a copay or coinsurance is your share of each bill; the out-of-pocket maximum caps what you pay in a year for covered care.
Compare these figures, not just the monthly premium. A low premium often comes with a high deductible.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov – glossary
Can I get health insurance at any time of year in the US?
USMarketplace plans can be bought during the annual Open Enrollment period, or at other times only if you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period after an event such as losing coverage, moving or having a baby.
Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program accept applications all year. Beware of sellers offering 'health plans' outside these routes; short-term and discount plans may not cover pre-existing conditions or essential benefits.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov – Special Enrollment Periods · HealthCare.gov
Can I get health insurance without a job in the US?
USYes. You can buy a Marketplace plan, often with income-based premium tax credits, or you may qualify for Medicaid depending on your income and state.
If you have just lost a job, you can usually keep your employer plan through COBRA, but you pay the full premium. Compare it with Marketplace prices; job loss gives you a Special Enrollment Period.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov · US Department of Labor – COBRA
Official help and where to check
- FCA Financial Services Register — check that an insurer, broker or comparison service is authorised
- FCA ScamSmart — check warnings about firms and scams
- Financial Ombudsman Service — free, independent route for unresolved complaints
- Financial Services Compensation Scheme — protection if an authorised insurer fails
- MoneyHelper — free, impartial guidance backed by government
- Citizens Advice — free advice on consumer problems
- NAIC – state insurance departments (US) — find your state insurance regulator and complaint process
- HealthCare.gov (US) — official US Marketplace for health coverage
The list above contains public bodies and non-profit services only. Any company named elsewhere on this site is mentioned for information only; we have no commercial relationship with any organisation named.
About this site
healthinsurance.ngo is a public-interest website of FINANCE TRANSPARENCY CIC, a non-profit community interest company registered in England and Wales (company number 17530096). It belongs to our Programme 2 · Household Costs & Debt. We sell nothing, carry no advertising and take no commission. The company is asset-locked, and its websites and domain names are used only for its community purpose and are not for sale.
About us, our principles and governance · Every source cited on this site · Corrections and right of reply: contact@healthinsurance.ngo